Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Spaghetti W/ Meatballs Or Meat Sauce
Supreme
Ravioli
Baked Lasagna
About
Tony's Pizza - Middleburg
Welcome to Tony's Pizza - Middleburg, where flavor meets quality in the heart of Middleburg, Florida. Located conveniently at 2219 County Rd 220, Tony’s has quickly become a local favorite for pizza lovers seeking that perfect slice. The inviting atmosphere and friendly service only enhance the experience as you dive into their extensive menu.
The star attraction here is undoubtedly the pizza. Patrons rave about the crust, which strikes the ideal balance between crispy and chewy, giving each bite a delightful texture. Customer Carly Martin couldn’t contain her excitement about the generous toppings and flavorful sauce, stating, “This pizza far exceeded my expectations!” It's this passion for quality and abundance that sets Tony’s apart. Even those who may have had mixed feelings about other menu items, like the wings, frequently return for the pizza that consistently impresses.
While some guests have noted the occasional shortfall in toppings, many still cherish the overall flavor profile and recommend diving into other options, such as the calzones, as allude by Kimberly Hunter. The commitment to delivering hot, delicious food, as reaffirmed by Yuriy Shvets, makes it a reliable choice for lunch or dinner. The care taken in crafting each dish is apparent through the feedback from satisfied diners who appreciate the prompt service and delectable meals.
But it’s not just about the pizza; the atmosphere is a draw in itself—fostering a sense of community and comfort. Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite or enjoying a meal with friends and family, Tony’s Pizza - Middleburg is the place to create memorable moments over a shared love for great food.
So, if you’re in the Middleburg area and craving a fulfilling pizza experience, look no further than Tony's. Come for the crust, stay for the camaraderie, and revel in the flavors that will turn you into a repeat customer! Don’t forget to bring cash for a better deal, as Tony's offers an excellent option for budget-conscious diners.
For orders, you can reach them at +1 904-375-9925. Your taste buds will thank you!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Tried them out as I’m looking for a pizza place whose pizza has an abundance of toppings and cheese so they were recommended. The pizza was very good, but was a little lacking in some of the toppings, so not what I was hoping for. The star is the crust though! Best pizza crust I’ve had in a long while. Crispy and chewy, but still soft. Even my husband commented on how good the flavor of the crust was. Great place, nice atmosphere and friendly service. Can’t wait to try their calzone. They also have a great menu with affordable prices. ”
“ Pizza was fantastic, but the wings not so much. Will buy pizza again just not the wings. We may even go for the other meals. Place smelled so amazing and of the other foods are as good as the pizza... Awesome... Just stay away from the wings. ”
“ Stopped here for the first time tonight to pick up carry out. Food was absolutely delicious, was ready exactly when they said it would be, and the staff was super polite. There are some negative reviews about the credit card pricing. This is ridiculous. They are giving you a cheaper option with cash instead of charging everyone higher to cover processing fees like 99% of the places in the south. This benefits customers and is the norm in a lot of places. ”
“ Stopped in the other day for the 1st time, overall great experience! Smaller place, but we got there when it wasn't busy so no issue there. It was really warm in there tho, and they didn't have music playing initially- but not a deal breaker bc the Mozzarella sticks were probably the best I've ever had! Could be wrong, but they seemed freshly made... The New York style Supreme pizza was delicious Will definitely be back! ”
“ First time trying pizza at Tony's... wow! I ordered an 18" pizza with pepperoni, sausage, and ham. The cheese and toppings were PILED ON! The sausage was sweet (not spicy) and the sauce was on the sweeter side, too. Delicious crust! I have zero complaints. This pizza far exceeded my expectations, and we will absolutely be repeat customers! ”
“ This is a small family run restaurant with authentic good food. The seating is minimal but when I went there wasn't much of a crowd so I was greeted and seated right away. The food was DELICIOUS. Every single thing we tasted was delicious. The garlic knots are out of this world. The prices are very reasonable ”
“ The pizza was very good. The service was terrible, but she was a very young girl, maybe new to the job. I would definitely go back. 9/20 We went back to Tony's today. Again, excellent food, but this time excellent service! Neveah said it was her first day, but we would never have known that. She was attentive and sweet, checking on us the perfect amount of times. ”
“ First time, had lunch special. Pizza was delicious, delivered hot, crispy crust, overall pleased with grabbing lunch here. ”